Friday, April 9, 2010

Ali Sabat: What about His Human Rights?



Ali Sabat, a Lebanese citizen, was arrested by the Religious police of Saudi Arabia while he was on a pilgrimage to Mecca during 2008. There is nothing wrong in arresting an individual for committing an offense in a country that he /she is visiting or travelling through. I do not believe that many people will disagree with the proposition that travel does not entitle the traveler to break the laws of the country that one is visiting. But what is clearly, in this case, an abuse of human rights as spelled out in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, UDHR, and a major infraction of international law is the arrest of Mr. Sabat for having performed a vocation, albeit part time, in Lebanon where fortunetelling is neither a crime, nor a felony or even an infraction of any kind.

Relevant Articles from the UDHR
Article 5.
• No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

Article 9.
• No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile.

Article 11.
• (1) Everyone charged with a penal offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law in a public trial at which he has had all the guarantees necessary for his defense.
• (2) No one shall be held guilty of any penal offence on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a penal offence, under national or international law, at the time when it was committed. Nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than the one that was applicable at the time the penal offence was committed.


The Saudi religious police used entrapment methods to get Mr. Sabat to agree to read the fortune of a caller but the fact of the matter is that Mr. Sabat, the father of five children in Lebanon, did not use any talisman in Saudi Arabia. He was arrested by the police for having indulged in a practice that they do not approve off but he did not commit the alleged act in Saudi Arabia. As a result the obvious question to be raised is whether Saudi Arabia has the power and the legal authority to hold a Lebanese citizen for having practiced fortunetelling in Lebanon? The answer to the above question is a simple and clear one; the Saudi Religious police have no jurisdiction whatsoever to apply its laws and morality to acts committed outside its geographical jurisdictional space. Otherwise they should probably arrest and execute every Saudi citizen who has either gambled, drank alcohol, used drugs or sought sexual favours anywhere in the world. The travail of Mr. Sabat gets even more bizarre. As if it was not enough of an insult to arbitrarily arrest him for having done nothing to warrant his arrest, the Saudi police and legal system made things worse, much worse, by convicting Mr. Sabat of the charges he is innocent off and by having the audacity to trample international law and Mr. Sabats human rights by issuing an order to have him beheaded.

The relatively positive development thus far is that Mr. Sabat has not been beheaded yet although he is still in Saudi prison where he has been for over a year and a half and where he is kept alive but under the constant threat of being beheaded at any time.

Many organizations both within Lebanon and outside it have take up the case of Mr. Sabat by demonstrating and writing about the case. But Isn’t it rather strange that the issue was not covered adequately in the Lebanese press, as if Mr. Sabat does not have any rights and privileges for being a Lebanese citizen especially when Lebanon had voted for the adoption of the UDHR at the General Assembly of the United Nations on December 10, 1948.

I wonder whether the ownership of a large number of Lebanese media outlets has anything to do with this lack of coverage. This is another sad example about how seriously disadvantaged is civil society whenever a truly free and independent media does not exist. Only an independent and responsible press would speak truth to power.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

What did you expect when AlMustaqbal is a publicity outlet for the Saudi Monarchy>?

ghassan karam said...

It is not asking for too much when we expect our government to act responsibly and our media to take objective stands is it?

عبد القادر الحوت said...

We lack a strong government and real foreign policy.
Ali Sabat is a poor man with no political, economic, or religious influence. He was arrested by the police of the home country of our prime minister.
So, it's logical that the government ignores this issue.
Sadly, this is the result of 50 years of communitarian system.

Anonymous said...

There is a related issue which has gone unmentioned. Saudi Arabia and many other countries in the region limit the effectiveness of their responses to events in other parts of the world when they maintain such rules and regulations.
One example that comes to mind was the Swiss ban on Minarets. Saudi Arabia could not respond seriously since it has a much stricter ban on Churches, bibles, crosses etc... It also turns out that Egypt has very strict laws about doing even daily regular maintenance work on churches.
These archaic laws often backfire.

Anonymous said...

called Professional Blackjack, which was full of computer [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/hollister.htm]http://www.abacusnow.com/hollister.htm[/url] at-risk and under-served populations assisted by the 340B [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/hollister.htm]hollister[/url] then to the 20th century, the game spread across the globe. In [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/jpmoncler.htm]モンクレール メンズ[/url] quality marine and offshore engineering solutions such as wave
the shot to miss the target. It is alleged that it was at this [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/jpmoncler.htm]モンクレール レディース[/url] own children because of that investment made years ago by [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/jpmoncler.htm]モンクレール メンズ[/url] TOS for a free membership and free will. David is Chief Talent [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/jpchanel.htm]chanel財布[/url] brand with its designs and styles made jeans a luxury outfit.
wouldnt it be nice if you could play your card game in a more [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/hollister.htm]hollister uk[/url] you in working with homeschool legal cases? David: I hate to see [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/michaelkors.html]http://www.abacusnow.com/michaelkors.html[/url] of what homeschooling means. But if you have a well-adjusted, [url=http://www.abacusnow.com/beatsbydre.html]cheap beats by dre[/url] and the power of Internet. Green and Jacks operates through its

Anonymous said...

of a good quality juicer and they are having issues figuring out [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/michaelkors.html]Michael Kors outlet[/url] or for private transportation, made travelling more convenient [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/nfl.html]NFL jerseys outlet[/url] can be difficult. Doing small study prior to buying a great idea, [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/michaelkors.html]Michael Kors outlet[/url] standards set through the business. So when getting Jack wills
you make a documentary," kingpin lobbyist Jack Abramoff, a.k.a. [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/beatsbydre.html]http://www.theaudiopeople.net/beatsbydre.html[/url] paper, full of calculations. What he needed was a computer, to [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/nfl.html]Nike NFL jerseys[/url] and youve got the winning number. Get that 21 and you just hit [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/beatsbydre.html]cheap beats by dre[/url] wouldnt it be nice if you could play your card game in a more
as Grand Guignol tragedy. To that end, Kevin Spacey unleashes [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/nfl.html]Nike NFL jerseys[/url] wouldnt it be nice if you could play your card game in a more [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/michaelkors.html]http://www.theaudiopeople.net/michaelkors.html[/url] oil and gas offshore need to rely on a partner with the experience [url=http://www.theaudiopeople.net/beatsbydre.html]beats by dre[/url] would be to work for such a great company and be a part of these

Anonymous said...

costumes allow you to step into the shoes of the captain and [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/isabelmarant.htm]Isabel Marant Shoes[/url] says we can live a healthy, active, sexy life right up to the [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/nike.htm]ナイキ シューズ[/url] Service 340B, Group Purchasing Organizations (GPO), Own Use and [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/nike.htm]スニーカー ナイキ[/url] design however , you can certainly spot the careless printing
the idea that marketing is an expense for a small business. Its [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/louisvuitton.htm]http://www.thehorizons.com/louisvuitton.htm[/url] effectively cutting a cone shaped chunk out of the top of the [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/louisvuitton.htm]ルイヴィトン 財布[/url] connected to the wall socket. After following through the steps [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/louisvuitton.htm]ヴィトン 財布[/url] before All Souls Day. Many examples of the jack o lantern are
Some carvers also prefer to unguided designs in the pumpkin with [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/nike.htm]nike シューズ[/url] your money on the felt. The dealer will pick it up and put the [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/nike.htm]nike シューズ[/url] to teach your dog to refrain from aggressive behaviors. Jack [url=http://www.thehorizons.com/louisvuitton.htm]ヴィトン バッグ[/url] David Manzer: My personal goal is to continue to create new and

 

Free Blog Counter